Market structure

The 1986 Big Bang: How the City of London Rewrote Its Own Rules

On a Monday in October 1986, a set of rule changes known as Big Bang opened London's stock exchange to competition and outside capital. Here is what changed, and why.

By the Sovereign Tradero editorial team Published Updated 5 min read

Picture this: a crowded, noisy hall in the City, men in dark suits standing at hexagonal pitches, and within a few months the same hall nearly silent, its business moved onto rows of screens in offices nearby.

That shift is the most visible image of Big Bang, the reforms that took effect at the London Stock Exchange on 27 October 1986. But the screens were a consequence, not the cause. The heart of Big Bang was a change in who was allowed to do what, and at what price.

The old club and its rules

Before 1986, the Stock Exchange ran on rules that had grown up over more than a century. Two features mattered most. The first was fixed minimum commissions: brokers charged clients according to a set scale, so they competed on service and contacts rather than on price. The second was single capacity. Members were either brokers, who acted as agents for clients, or jobbers, who dealt in shares on their own account and quoted prices to brokers. No firm could be both.

Membership was also restricted. Member firms were partnerships of individuals, and outside companies, including banks and foreign firms, could not own them outright. Many members were small, and the system worked comfortably for those inside it.

Supporters of the old rules had a case. Single capacity was meant to protect clients: a broker who could not deal on his own account had no reason to steer a client towards shares he wanted to sell. Fixed commissions, they argued, paid for research and for the time brokers spent with smaller investors. The question was whether those benefits were worth the lack of competition and the limits on capital that came with them.

Pressure from outside

By the late 1970s this structure was under strain. In 1979 the government abolished exchange controls, so British savers and institutions could invest abroad freely, and London had to compete with other financial centres. Large investors, such as pension funds, resented paying fixed commissions on very large orders. Meanwhile, New York had abolished fixed commissions in 1975.

The government's competition authority had also taken the Stock Exchange's rulebook to court, arguing that it restricted competition. In 1983 the Trade and Industry Secretary, Cecil Parkinson, and the Exchange's chairman, Sir Nicholas Goodison, agreed a compromise: the case would be dropped, and in return the Exchange would abolish fixed commissions by the end of 1986. Once that thread was pulled, the rest of the old structure unravelled.

The reason was simple economics. Without fixed commissions, broking alone would earn far less, and firms would need more capital and more ways to earn a living. Single capacity and the bar on outside owners became hard to justify, and the Exchange agreed to remove them as well.

What changed in 1986

The diagram below compares the basic route of a share order before and after the reforms.

Share orders before and after Big Bang Before 1986: a client goes to a broker, who pays a fixed commission scale and deals with a jobber on the floor. After 1986: a client goes to a combined firm that can act as broker and dealer, commissions are negotiated, and prices are shown on screens. Before Client Broker fixed commission Jobber on the floor After Client Combined firm negotiated fee Screen quotes from many firms
A simplified comparison. In practice, firms after 1986 were usually divided internally into separate teams.

Four changes came together. Minimum commissions were abolished, so fees became negotiable. Single capacity ended: firms could now act as both agent and principal, and the old jobbers were replaced by market makers who were obliged to quote prices. Outside ownership was allowed, and from earlier in 1986 banks, including foreign ones, could buy member firms outright. Finally, prices were displayed on a computer system called SEAQ, so dealers could work from their own offices.

On the day itself, the new systems struggled under heavy use in the morning, a reminder that the technology had been introduced in a hurry. The problems were fixed quickly, but they added to the sense that the City was learning a new way of working in public.

The aftermath

Many expected the floor to survive alongside the screens. Within months, it was almost empty. Large British and overseas banks had already bought many broking and jobbing firms, creating bigger, combined businesses with far more capital. Pay, hours and working culture in the City changed sharply, and new office developments, including the later towers of Canary Wharf, followed.

Regulation changed too. The Financial Services Act 1986 replaced much of the old self-regulation with a statutory framework, overseen by a new Securities and Investments Board and a set of self-regulating organisations. Critics worried that combined firms faced conflicts of interest, for example between advising clients and dealing on their own account, and later reforms returned to that question repeatedly.

Why Big Bang still matters

Big Bang is sometimes told as a story of sudden modernisation, and sometimes as the start of a riskier, more aggressive City. Both readings contain truth. The reforms opened a closed market to competition and capital, and they changed London's place among financial centres. They also show how rules, more than technology, decide the shape of a market: the screens arrived because the rules had first made them useful.

This article is educational content about economic history. It is not financial advice and does not recommend any investment, product or course of action.